Some homesites are simply hard to replace — this is one. This 1.24-acre lot in Island Acres offers space and privacy rarely found in a gated community, tucked quietly at the end of a cul-de-sac. Now offered at $84,900, it's also the most affordable acre-plus lot on the island. Island Acres is a small, close-knit community of just 31 homesites, built around Treasure Lake — a peaceful gathering spot with a lakeside pavilion, sandy beach, and calm water views. Residents enjoy a scenic perimeter trail for walking, jogging, or biking, along with private roads and underground utilities that keep the neighborhood clean, uncrowded, and unhurried. The lot is served by city water and septic, giving you the reliability of a public water connection paired with the flexibility of your own septic system — a great combination for a custom-built home in a natural setting. Lot 5 offers a wooded, natural landscape, with half the property preserved as conservation land, framing your future home with mature trees and a buffer from neighbors — a rare feature that makes this homesite feel more like a private retreat than a typical subdivision lot. And you're never far from everything Pine Island offers: waterfront dining, marinas, boat ramps, and local shopping are just minutes away. This is your opportunity to secure the largest, most private homesite in a gated Pine Island community—at a price that's tough to beat.
Property Details
- Lot Features
- Oversized Lot, Wooded
- Lot Description
- Oversized Lot, Wooded
- Acres
- 1.24
- Property Type
- Purchase
- Sewer Information
- Septic Needed
- Utility Source
- Public
- Utility Features
- Underground Utilities, Water Available
- Subdivision
- ISLAND ACRES SUB
- Community Features
- Gated Community - No Guard
- County
- Lee
- Region
- ST JAMES CITY
- Zoning
- RPD
- Original List Price
- $94,900
- Days on Market (Cumulative)
- 411
- Taxes Annual
- $723
- HOA
- 1
- HOA Fees
- 1196.0
- Pets
- 1
- Pets Allowed
- 1
- Ownership
- Fee Simple
- MLS #
- C7515374
- Property Subtype
- Land
- Parcel Number
- 33-44-22-01-00000.0050
- MLS #
- C7515374
- Date Listed
- September 23, 2025
- Address
- 9437 TREASURE LAKE COURT
Location
Legal
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. Listing Information presented by local MLS brokerage: George Fleischmann | AveNew Realty
Provided By
Listed by Kevin Daly (#MFR258007066)
Listing Office: CENTURY 21 SUNBELT REALTY (#MFR252000806)
